Nutricost vs Optimum Nutrition Creatine Monohydrate: Which One Deserves a Spot in Your Stack?

Written by our supplement testing crew
Built for lifters, athletes, and anyone serious about what they put in their body—this guide is written by real coaches who prioritize performance over hype.

---

---

Why Creatine Monohydrate Still Reigns Supreme

If you train hard, push for PRs, or simply want to build more strength and recover faster, creatine monohydrate is one of the few supplements that’s earned its place in almost every lifter’s stack. Backed by decades of research, creatine is clinically proven to support ATP production, improve power output, boost lean muscle mass, and speed up recovery between sets.

Out of all the creatine types out there—HCL, nitrate, buffered—the old-school monohydrate is still the gold standard. It’s affordable, effective, and proven.

But when it comes to which creatine monohydrate brand is worth your money, Nutricost and Optimum Nutrition are two of the biggest names on Amazon—and they each have a loyal following. So we broke them down head-to-head.

---

Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate: Budget-Friendly, Clean, and Effective

Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate is a widely recognized supplement designed to support athletic performance and enhance muscle recovery. Each serving provides a potent dose of creatine, which is crucial for energy production during high-intensity workouts. The recommended serving size of Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate is typically five grams, with a total of 100 servings per container, making it a convenient option for any training regimen.

Product Specs:

• Form: Micronized creatine monohydrate
• Serving Size: 5g
• Servings per Container: 100
• Cost Per Serving: ~$0.15
• Flavor: Unflavored
• Key Feature: No fillers, no sweeteners, just pure creatine

Why It’s Popular:
Nutricost keeps things simple and effective. You’re getting 100% pure micronized creatine monohydrate, which dissolves easily and has no extra ingredients to worry about. This is for athletes who want to maximize performance and recovery without overpaying or dealing with artificial sweeteners or flavors.

Who It’s For:

• Budget-conscious athletes
• Those who prefer unflavored, mixable powders
• Lifters focused on clean ingredients and value per scoop

What We Liked:

• Zero fluff—just pure creatine
• Mixes better than cheaper non-micronized options
• Great for stacking with other supplements
• One of the best price-to-quality ratios on Amazon

Potential Drawback:

• Slightly lower brand recognition than ON
• Fewer flavor options (only unflavored)

---

Optimum Nutrition Creatine Monohydrate: Trusted, Polished, and Athlete-Approved

Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Monohydrate Powder is a popular choice among fitness enthusiasts and athletes aiming to enhance their performance and recovery. With a focus on quality, this creatine supplement undergoes a micronization process that facilitates better solubility and absorption in the body, ensuring that users can maximize their creatine intake efficiently. Each serving of this product provides 5 grams of pure creatine monohydrate, which is the standard recommended dosage for most individuals looking to boost their muscle strength and endurance.

Product Specs:

• Form: Micronized creatine monohydrate
• Serving Size: 5g
• Servings per Container: 120
• Cost Per Serving: ~$0.25
• Flavor: Unflavored
• Key Feature: High solubility, backed by a legacy brand

Why It’s a Top Seller:
Optimum Nutrition is one of the most trusted names in sports nutrition—and for good reason. Their micronized creatine dissolves easily, leaves no grit at the bottom of your shaker, and consistently gets strong user reviews for effectiveness and quality control.

Who It’s For:

• Athletes who want a proven, consistent product
• Lifters who value brand trust and reputation
• Those who mix creatine with water, protein, or pre-workouts and want zero clumping

What We Liked:

• Micronized for smoother mixing
• From a top-tier, globally recognized brand
• Works well for high-volume or competitive athletes
• Often NSF certified for sport (depending on seller)

Potential Drawback:

• Higher price per serving
• Packaging can vary slightly (but product remains consistent)

---

Ingredient Breakdown: Are They Really That Different?

Let’s get real—both of these products use 100% creatine monohydrate. No fancy blends. No performance buzzwords. Just the stuff that actually works.

The difference lies in the micronization quality and manufacturing transparency.

• Nutricost gives you pure creatine with no fillers, no sweeteners, no fluff. It’s clean, effective, and reliable.
• Optimum Nutrition also gives you pure creatine, but with tighter quality controls, better solubility, and a reputation earned over years of consistent product output.

For ingredient purists, both check the boxes. But if you’re especially sensitive to GI discomfort or poor mixing, ON’s ultra-fine micronization might be worth the extra couple of cents per scoop.

---

Pricing & Value: What’s the Better Deal?

Here’s where it gets interesting:

Product	Total Servings	Approx. Price	Price per Serving
Nutricost	100 servings	~$15	$0.15/serving
Optimum Nutrition	120 servings	~$30	$0.25/serving

• Nutricost wins on affordability. If you’re going through a tub a month or have multiple athletes in your house using it, those savings add up fast.
• Optimum Nutrition wins on consistency and trust. You’re paying a premium, but you’re also getting one of the most reviewed and highest-rated creatines on the market.

---

Mixability and User Experience

Both products are micronized, but ON gets the slight edge in solubility and consistency—especially when mixed in plain water. Nutricost does just fine in shakes or with a blender bottle, but you may occasionally notice light residue.

Neither product has a taste, which is great for those who hate artificially flavored creatine.

---

Real Results: What Users Are Saying

Nutricost:

• “Started seeing strength increases after two weeks.”
• “Super easy to mix with my pre-workout.”
• “Clean, affordable, and effective—nothing else needed.”

Optimum Nutrition:

• “No stomach issues, no clumps—just results.”
• “My go-to creatine for over a year now.”
• “ON is a name I trust. Never had a bad batch.”

In general, Nutricost appeals to value-driven users who want a solid, no-BS creatine. ON attracts loyalists and advanced athletes who’ve used other brands and stick with what works.

---

Final Verdict: Nutricost vs Optimum Nutrition Creatine—Which One Should You Buy?

Choose Nutricost if you want:

• Affordable creatine without sacrificing quality
• A clean label without artificial extras
• A reliable, mixable powder that works with any stack

Choose Optimum Nutrition if you want:

• A brand backed by elite-level athletes
• Slightly better mixability and digestion
• The assurance of decades of consistent product quality

---

Bottom Line

Both Nutricost and Optimum Nutrition deliver high-quality creatine monohydrate that supports strength, recovery, and performance. The real difference comes down to budget, brand preference, and your supplement priorities.

If you’re just starting out or stacking multiple products, go with Nutricost. If you’re an experienced lifter or trust Optimum Nutrition with the rest of your stack, ON is a safe, solid bet.

Either way, you’re getting creatine that works.

---

If you found this article helpful, or would like to see more content like this. Consider checking out our Blog page here!